Michael Schmidt, Raw Milk Activist, Acquitted!

Michael Schmidt has been fighting for the rights of his herd share members to consume raw milk for the last three years. The National Post said today: “Justice of the Peace Paul Kowarsky upheld the legislation, but said in this case Mr. Schmidt did not break the law because he was distributing to joint owners of cows and not the public at large.”

The Globe and Mail today describes the issue as: “really about the extent to which consumers should be free to buy foods, however rarefied, and whether constitutional rights stretch as far as the grocery basket, farmer’s market and the people who own shares in – but do not live on – food producing farms.

This is not just about raw milk, this is about people’s rights to choose whatever foods they want. I advocate for choice, said Joseph Heckman, an organic farming expert at Rutger’s University in New Jersey who has consumed raw milk since childhood and now studies it.”

The court has upheld our individual rights to hire someone to care, milk and pasture animals. They have upheld our rights to jointly own a herd of animals. This ruling may be appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada. But right now, Michael Schmidt can go back to the business of running his farm.

Updated January 23, 2010: Patricia Meyer-Watt CNP From the Weston A Price Foundation Toronto Chapter posted this article from the Toronto Star about Michael Schmidt’s acquittal. The essence of why herd share programs are legal is outlined in the following statement: “Schmidt has long maintained he does not break the law by providing milk to the cow?s owners, all of whom purchase a portion of the cow and pay to board the animal at Glencolton Farms. The prohibition on raw milk in Ontario does not apply to farmers drinking raw milk from their own cows. [Justice of the Peace Paul] Kowarsky ruled Schmidt?s cow-share program did not break the law because the farmer only provided milk and raw milk products to his members, did not advertise or market his operation, and that cow-share members were aware they consumed milk at their own risk.”

Updated April 5, 2010: If you would like to read the Judgment from His Worship P. Kowarsky Justice of the Peace for Regina V M. Schmidt on January 21, 2010.

7 thoughts on “Michael Schmidt, Raw Milk Activist, Acquitted!

  1. Fraser Health’s case against Chilliwack’s herd-share is going to be heard on Feb 1.

    What a great news that a judge in ON gave a common sense verdict – showing respect to our right to own part of a herd to get our milk harvested by a contracted farmer~!

    To be honest I’m anxious about our case, but for now, I’ll just focus on what I need to do to keep the farm going.

  2. Hi Sui,

    Michael Schmidt’s acquittal is good news for all of us. I have a great sense of gratitude to the court that they upheld our right to jointly own a herd and to contract the housing, milking and pasturing of the herd.

    At the same time, I have a sense of outrage that we have to “fight” for such a simple “right”.
    1. Are we as a population slowly loosing the choice of where we get our food because of government regulation in the name of “safety”?
    2. How many regular individuals would have the personal strength and resources to battle the government in the courts? I know, I couldn’t.

  3. Pingback: Kamloops Herdshare Program

  4. Pingback: BC Supreme Court Gives Injunction Against Raw Milk

  5. Pingback: Helping Michael Schmidt, Raw Milk Activist

  6. Pingback: Ontario Court Reverses Lower Decision for Raw Milk Farmer

  7. Pingback: Raw Milk Contamination?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *